Picture this. You've just landed in Atlanta, you've waited two hours for your suitcase and when the bags finally start rolling out, they're covered in thick brown goo.
That's what happened to passengers on American Airlines flight 2609 from Miami on Monday night, and the panic at baggage claim was immediate. As dozens of smeared suitcases came around the carousel at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport, travelers started shouting the same thing: this is poop.
A passenger's video of the moment has reportedly passed 1.3 million views on TikTok. In it, you can hear the horror build as bag after bag comes out coated in the brown mess. "Oh my God" is about the politest thing anyone says.


What It Actually Was
Good news for everyone's stomachs: it wasn't poop.
American Airlines says it was peanut butter. According to the airline, a jar in one passenger's checked bag leaked during the flight and spread onto the suitcases around it.
"Unfortunately, a food item from a customer's checked bag leaked during the flight, affecting several bags nearby," American said in a statement. The airline added that the substance was confirmed after an environmental inspection, and that its team "will work directly with the affected customers to make it right."
Not everyone is buying it. The passenger who filmed the video reportedly asked the obvious question: how much peanut butter does one person pack to cover that many bags? It's a fair point. Either someone was flying with a truly heroic amount of peanut butter, or a jar met a very unlucky spot in the cargo hold.
How Peanut Butter Ends Up Everywhere
This one made me laugh and wince at the same time. But it's less crazy than it sounds.
Cargo holds get bumped around a lot, and checked bags get stacked tightly on top of each other. Jars can crack and lids can pop. Once something oily starts leaking in a packed hold, it doesn't stay in one suitcase for long. Your neighbor's snack becomes everyone's problem.
The two-hour wait didn't help either. Passengers were already frustrated before the first bag appeared, and then many of them ended up cleaning their luggage with wipes and tissues right there at the carousel. Not exactly the welcome to Atlanta anyone wanted.
What to Do If Your Bag Comes Out Ruined
If this ever happens to you, the most important thing is speed. American gives you only six hours after getting your bag on a US domestic flight to report damage, or you can report it before you leave the airport. After an international trip, you get seven days.
Take photos before you wipe anything down, since that's your proof. Then report it at the baggage office or by scanning the QR code sign at baggage claim, and save the file number American gives you. You'll need it to file a claim for cleaning or replacing anything that got ruined.
And if you're the one packing the peanut butter, double bag it. Better yet, keep it sealed in a zip-top bag inside your suitcase. If you'd rather carry it on, remember that security treats peanut butter like a liquid, so anything over 3.4 ounces has to go in your checked bag.
American has had a rough run with food lately, from its catering problems at a major hub to this sticky situation in Atlanta. If your American trip goes sideways in other ways, the airline also now lets you stand by for an earlier flight in the app without losing your seat.