> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.thecontrail.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# I Got Upgraded to First Class for Free. I Still Wouldn't Pay for It
- URL: https://www.thecontrail.org/is-domestic-first-class-worth-it/
- Published: 2026-11-21T19:47:45.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-21T19:47:45.000Z
- Description: I flew American's domestic first class from LaGuardia to Tampa and Charlotte to JFK. The free drinks were nice, but for what it costs, economy wins.
- Author: Ava Castro
- Tags: Editorial, American

I flew domestic first class from LGA to TPA and CLT to JFK via American; I enjoyed the experience and overall treatment, but that was only because I got upgraded for free. Domestic first class is definitely nice, but not worth the price tag. Flying domestically through the U.S. is already expensive, so adding hundreds to even thousands of dollars to the price tag for the upgrade is not worth it. I understand that people want to feel bougie, but honestly, that bougie feeling no longer exists on many airlines. For the exorbitant price tag, the luxury just isn't there. Zach, editor-in-chief of Contrail, who’s been on God knows how many domestic flights, even says that “domestic first isn’t worth it much unless you have the money to spend or need extra space. It has become more the illusion of being in first class than actually fully enjoying it. The minimal differences from the economy highlight a growing trend in the last few decades with passenger experience (pax ex) getting less attention, though this can be seen as a good thing because it lowers costs and makes flying more accessible to all.”

---

## What You Get

Domestic first class does have perks. When I flew CLT to JFK, I was treated to extra drinks, warm nuts, additional snacks, some great legroom, a nice recline, and hands-on service. I even got a meal since the flight was over 2 hours. First class allots its passengers free alcohol, yay, tequila in the air! But even better, and I know it can't get much better than that, you get free checked bags and extra airline points! Although there are benefits, the seats are generally still uncomfortable, and many older planes don't have USB-C or an outlet, so, for me, I wasn't able to charge my phone, which sucked. Unfortunately, domestic first class has become pretty mediocre, and you can no longer aura farm and flex on your friends. I’ll still post an Instagram story, but I'm not proud of it.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/ac/ed/acedfbb2-ff9c-499b-b431-eb36d7539be1/content/images/2026/11/IMG_1460.jpg)

Delta regional First Class Credit: Zach

---

## Benefits of Economy

Economy is, without question, way cheaper and typically easier to book since there's more seats to choose from. Traveling with friends, family, or a coworker you're chill with? Economy lets groups sit together. The seats in economy may not be saving room for Jesus, but that's okay; it makes it easier to eavesdrop and be in strangers' business. I like to view it as bonding. As a chronically nosy person, I love listening to conversations that have nothing to do with me. The wider variety of seat prices and exponential price difference really sells economy as the better option. Also, if you're just flying domestically within the U.S., the flight isn't long enough for you to be desperate for first class. DEN to MSY (Denver to New Orleans) doesn't need a first-class seat; even JFK to LAX is doable. That said, some premium transcontinental routes, like JFK to LAX or San Francisco, have lie-flat seats up front, which is a different experience entirely. The great thing is, you can still complain to your friends about it via text while I look over at your phone. So, there are upsides to everything.

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/ac/ed/acedfbb2-ff9c-499b-b431-eb36d7539be1/content/images/2026/11/IMG_9638-2-1.JPG)

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/ac/ed/acedfbb2-ff9c-499b-b431-eb36d7539be1/content/images/2026/11/IMG_9647-2.jpg)

---

## Flying Economy Makes the Trip Better

The simplest reason why flying economy is best for vacations is because you'll have more money for your trip. You'll be saving hundreds and sometimes thousands of dollars, which can be put towards shopping, spa days, luxury hotels, fancy dinners, and more. Why steal your husband's credit card for some extra legroom when you can go to Tiffany's instead? Flying economy makes you more grateful for your trip, which makes the vacation better, in my opinion.